John Mozeliak Acknowledges That Ruining the Cardinals’ Chances of Winning in 2025 Would Be Selfish.
In a candid moment during an interview, St. Louis Cardinals president of baseball operations, John Mozeliak, addressed the critical juncture the franchise finds itself at as it prepares for the future. Mozeliak’s acknowledgment of the delicate balance between rebuilding and competing has garnered significant attention, particularly his assertion that making decisions that could damage the team’s chances of winning in 2025 would be “selfish.” His comments reflect the weight of responsibility he feels as the architect of the team’s future success while trying to keep fans engaged and hopeful for a playoff-contending team in the near term.
With the Cardinals’ performance in 2023 and 2024 falling short of expectations, a serious evaluation of the team’s roster, its long-term goals, and its immediate needs is underway. The franchise, which has built a reputation for its consistency and championship pedigree, is now navigating a crossroads, facing pressure from both the fanbase and the front office to rebuild while not sacrificing the competitive window for the coming years.
The Pressure of Immediate Expectations
For the St. Louis Cardinals, expectations are always high. With a loyal and passionate fan base that has grown accustomed to success, particularly in the form of frequent playoff appearances and two World Series titles in the last two decades, anything less than contention feels like a failure. In recent seasons, however, the team has struggled to find the right formula. The Cardinals entered the 2024 season with high hopes, only to find themselves struggling with injuries, inconsistent pitching, and a lack of cohesion throughout the roster.
In an organization known for stability and a philosophy of maintaining competitive teams, the idea of a “rebuild” was not taken lightly. Mozeliak, who has overseen the team’s operations for more than a decade, understands that any moves that signal a complete departure from the current roster—such as trading off key veterans, including cornerstone players like Paul Goldschmidt or Nolan Arenado—would be difficult, not only for the fans to accept but for the team’s future direction.
The 2025 season is seen by many as a critical year for the franchise. As Mozeliak himself stated, “We don’t want to be in a situation where we look back and realize that the choices we made in 2024 and 2025 ended up costing us the chance to win. The competitive window is there, but it’s fragile.” While some of the team’s veteran players are entering their twilight years, the foundation remains strong in key positions, and there are several young players, like Jordan Walker and Dylan Carlson, poised to take on larger roles.
Yet, the looming question of how to best position the team for success while balancing the rebuilding process has made for some tense conversations within the front office. Should the Cardinals go all-in for one last push with the current group? Or is it time to start focusing on future seasons and making moves that could set up the team for sustained success in the years beyond 2025?
Mozeliak’s Self-Awareness and Responsibility
Mozeliak’s acknowledgment of the potential harm in “ruining the chances” of competing in 2025 reveals a level of self-awareness and responsibility that is often underappreciated in the world of professional sports. With the Cardinals coming off a disappointing 2023 season—one that saw them miss the playoffs for the first time in several years—Mozeliak has been under intense scrutiny. Fans, while loyal, have grown frustrated with the team’s inability to consistently perform at the level they expect.
The idea that making short-sighted decisions could jeopardize the team’s prospects for success in 2025, or potentially longer, is a reality Mozeliak is clearly grappling with. “It would be selfish of me to make a decision that sacrifices the future for a fleeting moment of competitiveness,” he said. “We have to build something that can sustain itself, but we also have to be mindful of the present. It’s a fine line to walk.”
This statement underscores the delicate balance Mozeliak faces: the need to be competitive now while keeping one eye firmly on the future. It’s a balance that every general manager or president of baseball operations must contend with, but for the Cardinals, with their storied history of success, the stakes are higher. Mozeliak understands that a rebuild, if handled poorly, could lead to long-term mediocrity—a fate that no team in St. Louis wants to face.
### The Cardinals’ Competitive Window and the Key Decisions Ahead
Looking ahead to 2025, Mozeliak has made it clear that the Cardinals’ goal is to position themselves as legitimate contenders. While it may be tempting to pull the plug on certain veterans or make drastic moves that could accelerate the team’s transition into a rebuild, Mozeliak insists that any changes must be strategic, focused on maintaining a competitive edge without mortgaging the team’s future.
“We can’t afford to give away a year or two of contention just for the sake of turning over a roster,” Mozeliak added. “That would be selfish and unfair to the fans. We owe it to them, and to our young players, to put together a team that has a chance to compete for championships in the near future, while also ensuring we’re developing talent for the long haul.”
One of the key questions for the Cardinals is what to do with their aging core of stars. Both Goldschmidt and Arenado are entering the back end of their careers, and while they remain productive, it’s unclear how long they will continue to be the centerpieces of the offense. Their trade value could be significant, but the impact of losing them in 2024 or 2025 would also be a significant blow to the team’s chances of competing.
Another critical decision for Mozeliak is the pitching staff. The team’s starting rotation has been inconsistent, and although there are promising arms in the minor leagues, the Cardinals’ immediate pitching needs are pressing. Should Mozeliak trade for a top-tier pitcher to anchor the rotation in 2025, or should the focus shift to developing internal talent and giving younger pitchers the opportunity to prove themselves?
The Future and the Cardinal Way
In many ways, Mozeliak’s comments about not being selfish reflect the broader values of the “Cardinal Way,” the philosophy of developing talent from within and creating a culture that values winning while maintaining a commitment to sustainability. The Cardinals have long prided themselves on a well-organized system that balances present and future success, and Mozeliak’s leadership is no different. As the team approaches 2025, it is clear that a delicate balance will need to be struck between short-term aspirations and long-term growth.
As the 2024 season progresses and moves are made, the decisions Mozeliak and the Cardinals make in the coming months will set the tone for the future. They have a roster with pieces that could lead to success if managed carefully, and Mozeliak’s acknowledgment of the weight of these decisions only emphasizes the responsibility he feels to keep the team competitive, both now and in the years to come. If the Cardinals can find that balance, 2025 could be a year where the team returns to the playoff picture and beyond, while ensuring that their future is even brighter.
Leave a Reply