DEA DONE: Why the Carolina Panthers Will Not Hesitate to Replace Bryce Young in 2025
The 2023 NFL season marked a new chapter for the Carolina Panthers, with the team selecting Bryce Young, the talented and highly touted quarterback from Alabama, as their number one overall pick in the NFL Draft. Hopes were high that the Panthers had found their franchise quarterback—someone capable of leading the team back to relevance after years of mediocrity. However, by the time the 2025 season rolls around, there is a strong possibility that the Carolina Panthers may not hesitate to move on from Bryce Young if his performance doesn’t meet expectations. This scenario may seem surprising to some, but in the fast-paced, high-stakes world of the NFL, where winning is everything, the team’s front office and coaching staff are bound to make tough decisions, and the quarterback position is arguably the most critical one of all.
1. High Expectations and the Urgency to Win
When the Panthers selected Bryce Young with the first overall pick in 2023, they were hoping to make a swift transition from their rebuilding phase to playoff contention. The 2023 season presented a fresh start, with new head coach Frank Reich at the helm and the promise of an exciting young quarterback to lead the offense. In a league where success is often measured by playoff appearances, divisional titles, and Super Bowl aspirations, there’s little room for patience if a highly drafted quarterback doesn’t deliver quickly. The Panthers have invested heavily in Young’s potential, but if he fails to meet those lofty expectations by the start of the 2025 season, they may be forced to reassess his future with the team.
The quarterback position in the NFL has a significant level of scrutiny placed on it. Whether it’s a fanbase desperate for a long-term answer at the position or an impatient ownership group with championship aspirations, expectations are extremely high. For the Panthers, who haven’t been to the playoffs since 2017 and have undergone a series of coaching and quarterback changes in recent years, there will be increasing pressure to show signs of progress.
In 2025, the Panthers’ ownership could face tough choices. If Young has struggled to take the team to the next level, the organization may not have the luxury of waiting much longer, especially given the significant talent in the NFL draft and the potential for other quarterbacks to emerge as game-changers. With young quarterbacks like Patrick Mahomes, Justin Herbert, and Joe Burrow leading their respective teams to success early in their careers, the NFL is increasingly becoming a league where instant success is expected, especially for top draft picks.
2. The NFL’s Quarterback Pressure Cooker
The NFL is not known for its patience when it comes to quarterbacks, particularly those taken early in the draft. Teams invest heavily in top picks, and the pressure for immediate results can be overwhelming. For Bryce Young, this means that even a couple of seasons of underperformance could lead to a quick and brutal evaluation of his potential to lead the Panthers into the future.
In recent years, there have been multiple instances of teams pulling the plug on highly drafted quarterbacks after only a few seasons. Josh Rosen, selected 10th overall by the Arizona Cardinals in 2018, was out of the team’s plans just one season later. Likewise, the Miami Dolphins quickly moved away from Tua Tagovailoa’s early struggles, with media speculation and fan pressure playing a role in how the Dolphins shaped their quarterback plans. While Tua has ultimately turned into a promising signal-caller under Mike McDaniel, his early struggles showed how easily a team’s confidence in its quarterback can erode.
Bryce Young, despite his impressive college career, has not yet proven anything at the NFL level. If he struggles with accuracy, decision-making, or overall development during his first two seasons, the Panthers’ brass may not hesitate to look for alternatives. This is particularly true when considering that quarterbacks often see the field earlier than ever before in today’s NFL, with many teams opting to develop their young signal-callers quickly.
3. The Urge to Win Now
The Carolina Panthers, under new ownership and with a front office that is eager to establish itself as competitive in the NFC South, will be impatient to start winning. This is not a team in the midst of a prolonged rebuild; they want to win now. Frank Reich, a head coach with considerable experience, is tasked with turning the Panthers around quickly. The pressure on Reich to show improvement on the field will be immense, and the team’s quarterback situation will be a huge factor in that equation.
If Bryce Young shows signs of being unable to elevate the Panthers’ offense, especially in a division like the NFC South—which has seen fluctuating quarterback play over the past few seasons—the team might be quick to pivot. With the likes of the Atlanta Falcons, New Orleans Saints, and Tampa Bay Buccaneers all attempting to figure out their own quarterback situations, the division remains in flux, creating an opportunity for the Panthers to capitalize on their competition if they have the right pieces in place.
If Young does not progress as hoped, Carolina may look to either move on from him or explore other options to bring in a quarterback capable of leading them to success in the short term. They may be willing to trade for a veteran quarterback, or—if they do not see Young’s development improving—they may select another promising signal-caller in the 2025 NFL Draft.
4. The Quarterback Carousel and Available Talent
In 2025, the NFL will likely be filled with talented quarterbacks who could be available to the Panthers. Teams that are underperforming may look to move on from their own quarterbacks, and several high-profile prospects will be available in the draft. The Panthers may find themselves in a position where a better option is available either in free agency, through a trade, or through the draft, and they will not hesitate to make the tough decision to replace Bryce Young.
This constant quarterback carousel has become a hallmark of the modern NFL. Teams regularly move on from underperforming quarterbacks, even if they’ve invested significant resources in them. Whether it’s through trades, free-agent signings, or draft picks, NFL teams are always on the lookout for that franchise quarterback who can lead them to a Super Bowl. If Bryce Young’s performance in his first two seasons does not meet those high expectations, the Panthers will likely explore other avenues to improve their quarterback situation. Given the evolving landscape of the NFL, where quarterbacks can change teams quickly, Carolina will be ready to pull the trigger if needed.
5. Bryce Young’s Development and What Could Go Wrong
Bryce Young, despite his immense college success, will need time to adjust to the speed and complexity of the NFL. Quarterbacks drafted early often face significant growing pains, especially those who are smaller in stature, like Young. His ability to process the game quickly, deal with the physical demands of the NFL, and elevate the play of those around him will be critical in determining his future.
However, if Young’s transition to the NFL proves more difficult than expected, and the Panthers are not seeing significant progress by the 2025 season, the team may need to make the hard decision to cut ties with their former first overall pick. Young has been lauded for his poise and leadership, but the NFL is an unforgiving environment, and all it takes is a few missed throws, turnovers, or a lack of development to make the team seriously question their investment.
6. Conclusion: The Stakes for Bryce Young
In conclusion, while Bryce Young is undoubtedly a promising talent, the 2025 season will be a critical juncture for both him and the Carolina Panthers. The team is in a situation where they can’t afford to waste time in a conference filled with young, talented quarterbacks and competitive rosters. If Young’s performance does not meet expectations, the Panthers will not hesitate to move on from him. With the stakes so high, Carolina’s front office, coaching staff, and ownership will make the decision they feel is best for the long-term success of the team, even if that means parting ways with a player they invested so heavily in just two years prior.
In today’s NFL, where success is expected immediately, the Panthers may not have the luxury of waiting for Bryce Young to develop at his own pace. The team needs results, and if Young cannot deliver, they will look to make a change at quarterback—and they will do so without hesitation.
Leave a Reply